Augustine of Hippo

Personal life

Augustine of Hippo (354–430) was born in Thagaste, in North Africa. Son of a Christian mother (Monica) and a pagan father, he was a brilliant young man devoted to the study of rhetoric. During his youth he led a worldly life and joined Manichaeism, a dualist doctrine that he followed for almost ten years. He had a son, Adeodatus, with a companion whose name he does not mention.

Seeking a better career he traveled to Rome and then to Milan, where he met Bishop Ambrose and drew close to Neoplatonism. After an intense inner crisis, he experienced his famous conversion in 386, recorded in the Confessions. He was baptized in 387 together with his son.

He returned to Africa, founded a community dedicated to study, and later was ordained priest almost against his will. In 396 he became Bishop of Hippo, a role he exercised for more than 30 years. From there he wrote fundamental works such as Confessions, The City of God, and On the Trinity, as well as combating the Manichaean, Donatist, and Pelagian heresies.

He died in 430, during the siege of Hippo by the Vandals, leaving a body of work that profoundly marked Western philosophy and theology.

Education and studies

Grammar and Latin literature
Rhetoric (principal discipline and professionalization)
Philosophy (self-taught: Cicero, Manichaeism, skepticism, and Neoplatonism)
Theology and the Bible (especially after his conversion)

His education was that typical of a high-level Roman intellectual, completed by an intense personal philosophical search.

What books did he write?

He wrote more than 100 works, among books, treatises, letters, and sermons. In total, the “Corpus Augustinianum” is enormous and continues to be edited and studied. The two works that everyone immediately associates with him are the Confessions and The City of God. We will name some:

Autobiographical and philosophical
- Confessions (Confessiones, 397–400): His autobiographical and spiritual masterpiece, considered one of the first memoir books in history. It is an autobiography and a dialogue with God where he narrates his life, his conversion, and his theological and philosophical reflections.
- Soliloquies (Soliloquia, 386–387), On the Happy Life (De beata vita, 386), Against the Academics (Contra Academicos, 386), On Order (De ordine, 386), On the Teacher (De magistro, 389)
Apologetic and polemical
- The City of God (De civitate Dei, 413–426): His great theological and historical work, written after the sack of Rome by the Visigoths in 410. In it, Saint Augustine develops the distinction between the "City of God" (the community of those who live according to God) and the "Earthly City" (the community of those who live according to man).
- On Christian Doctrine (De doctrina christiana, 396–427), Against the Manichees (various works, among them De moribus ecclesiae catholicae et de moribus manichaeorum, De libero arbitrio, etc.), Against the Donatists (many works, such as Contra epistulam Parmeniani, Psalmus contra partem Donati, etc.), Against the Pelagians (very important late works): On Grace and Free Will (De gratia et libero arbitrio), On the Predestination of the Saints (De praedestinatione sanctorum), On the Gift of Perseverance (De dono perseverantiae), Against Julian (in defense of original sin).

What was Augustine of Hippo’s ethical thought?

The ethical thought of Saint Augustine of Hippo is one of the fundamental bases of Christian and Western morality, centering on the love of God as the source of all virtue and good.

Concept	Description
The supreme good is God	For Augustine, ethics begins by recognizing that the human being was created to seek and love God. Everything good participates in the absolute Good, which is God; therefore, morality consists in ordering life toward Him.
Evil is not a substance, but a privation	Moral evil is not something that exists by itself, but a lack of good, a disorder. Evil arises when the will chooses inferior things instead of the supreme Good.
The will is the center of morality	Augustine is the first great philosopher who places the emphasis on the will (not only on reason). To act well, the will must be correctly oriented. Sin is a misuse of freedom, choosing badly through pride, desire, or disorder.
Grace is necessary for the moral good	For Augustine, the human condition is weakened by sin and cannot by itself reach moral perfection. The human being can choose, but needs divine grace to orient his will toward the good.
Intention matters more than the exterior action	Moral value does not depend only on what is done, but on why it is done. A good action done out of vanity is not morally good.
Virtues are forms of ordered love	Augustine redefines the classical virtues (prudence, fortitude, temperance, justice) as ways of loving correctly, and not as mere rational habits as in Aristotle.
Happiness is union with God	The ultimate end of the human being and foundation of ethics is beatitude, which is only fully reached in God. The ethical life is a path of purification of desire and the will to orient them toward that end.

What did he think about the State?

Keep in mind that when Augustine lived, the concept of the State “did not exist.”

Aspect	Summary of Augustine’s thought
Origin of the State	It arises from sin; it is not natural to the human being. Authority appears to contain evil.
Nature of the State	It is part of the Earthly City: imperfect, limited, marked by human ambition.
End of the State	To guarantee temporal peace, civil order, and protection against injustice.
Justice and legitimacy	A State is legitimate when it exercises justice. Without justice, it is “a band of robbers.”
Political authority	Necessary to limit the disorder caused by sin; its authority comes from God, but is imperfect.
Obedience to the State	Citizens must obey except when the State commands something unjust or contrary to God.
Relation to salvation	The State cannot save the human being. Salvation belongs only to the City of God.
Can the State use force?	Yes. Augustine justified state coercion against heretics (Donatists) when it is necessary and proportionate to protect peace and unity.

What criticisms did his ideas receive?

NOTE:

The Pelagians (360–418) believed that man can be saved fundamentally by his own efforts and that he does not need a special grace that heals and interiorly moves his will. Augustine and the Catholic Church (and later most Protestant churches) defended the opposite: without the free and interior grace of Christ no one can be saved or persevere in the good.
The Donatists (4th century until the 8th century) were rigorist African Christians who, after the persecution of Diocletian, broke with the official Church because it accepted clergy who had faltered and collaborated with the Roman State. They wanted an absolutely pure Church and considered invalid the sacraments of the “impure.” Saint Augustine was their great opponent and, in the end, the Catholic Church and the Empire repressed them until they were extinguished.

Theme	Main criticism	Principal critics	Main period
Grace and predestination	Augustine went too far: God predestines some to hell without giving them sufficient grace (seems unjust and makes God the author of evil)	Pelagius and Celestians (5th century), semi-Pelagians (Marseille), Jesuits/Molinists (16th–17th centuries), modern theologians	5th–17th and today
Original sin and transmission	He exaggerated the total corruption of human nature and the transmission of sin through sexual concupiscence (seems to blame sex)	Pelagians, Renaissance humanists, modern Protestant and Catholic liberal theology	5th–20th
Use of state coercion against heretics	He justified religious persecution (letters 93 and 185). He broke with the tradition of tolerance of the early Christians	Donatists (in his time), Erasmus, Sebastian Castellio, Voltaire, Locke, Baptists, modern liberals	16th–21st
Negative vision of sex and the body	Too pessimistic: he saw concupiscence as almost invincible and sexual pleasure always suspect	Humanists, romantics, Freud, contemporary theologians of the body (John Paul II nuances, but recognizes the Augustinian excess)	15th–21st
The State as a “necessary evil”	He undervalues politics and public life too much; opens the door to quietism or to Church-State dualism	Thomas Aquinas (corrects and “revalues” the political), Jesuit theologians of the 16th–17th centuries, Catholic theorists of the common good	13th–20th
Slavery	He did not clearly condemn it and accepted it as a consequence of sin (De civ. Dei XIX, 15)	Gregory of Nyssa (4th century), Christian abolitionists (18th–19th centuries), liberation theology	18th–20th
Just war	Although he regulated it, his justification of state force facilitated later wars and crusades	Christian pacifists (Tolstoyans, Mennonites, Quakers), modern theologians of peace	19th–21st
Allegorical interpretation of the Bible	He abused allegory to “spiritualize” uncomfortable texts (e.g. violence of the Old Testament)	Protestant literalists, some modern Catholic exegetes	16th–20th
Vision of women	Harsh phrases about Eve and woman as a subordinate “helper” (although he also says that in Christ there is neither male nor female)	Christian and secular feminists, contemporary theologians	20th–21st

The most repeated criticism throughout history: “Augustine is too pessimistic about human nature and too hard on the body, sex, and freedom” (this criticism goes from Pelagius in the 5th century to many theologians and thinkers today).

The Church has always held that, read in context and with later nuances (especially Trent and recent magisterium), Augustine’s fundamental intuitions on grace and original sin remain Catholic truth.

What criticisms did his personal life receive?

Almost all serious criticisms start from what he himself confessed: Augustine wrote the Confessions precisely to show his past misery and the mercy of God. That is why it is very hard to accuse him of grave hypocrisy: he was the first to scourge himself.
The harshest criticisms (especially the abandonment of the concubine and the alleged “marriage of convenience”) are exaggerated: in that era it was normal for an ambitious professor to seek a socially advantageous marriage, and he himself recounts that he suffered greatly when separating from her («they tore from my side a part of myself»).
Today the most repeated and emotional criticism is that of the abandonment of the mother of his son, seen from current sensibility as cruelty or sexism.

Augustine is probably the saint to whom one can least reproach for hiding his past… because he published it himself in full detail! Most criticisms of his personal life are in reality criticisms that he dared to tell the truth so crudely.

What is his legacy?

Augustine is the great bridge between the ancient world and the Middle Ages, and the thinker who has most marked the theology, spirituality, psychology, and vision of history of the West for 1,600 years.

Today he remains:

The most cited Doctor of the Church.
The most read non-biblical Christian author after the Bible.
A reference figure both for Catholics and for Protestants (and even for atheist philosophers who admire him as a psychologist).

Area	Main legacy	Historical impact
Christian theology	Founder of Western theology: doctrine of original sin, grace, Trinity.	Profoundly influenced the Catholic Church, medieval thought, the Reformation (Luther, Calvin), and modern theology.
Philosophy	Development of philosophies of the will, interiority, and time; evil as privation; ethics of the order of love.	Inspired medieval philosophers, existentialists, phenomenologists, and modern thinkers (such as Husserl or Heidegger on the concept of time).
Ethics	Primacy of the will and of ordered love; moral intention as the center of action.	Paves the way for medieval Christian ethics and modern ethics centered on intention.
Political philosophy	Vision of the State as a response to sin; distinction between City of God and Earthly City.	Basis of the medieval Christian conception of power; influenced political theory into modernity.
Spirituality	Focus on interiority, the search for God within the soul, and examination of conscience.	Influence on monastic spirituality, on mysticism, and on the tradition of Christian introspection.
Biblical exegesis	Use of allegorical and philosophical interpretations; method of spiritual reading of Scripture.	Basis of centuries of biblical interpretation in the West.
Literature	Confessions as the first great spiritual and psychological autobiography in history.	Masterpiece of world literature, model of introspection and personal narrative.
Philosophical anthropology	Development of a vision of the human being as an interior being, with fragmented will and need of grace.	Influences all of Christian anthropology and part of modern philosophy of subjectivity.
Education and pedagogy	Ideas about teaching as a guide toward interior truth, not mere transmission of information.	Influenced medieval and Renaissance Christian educational models.

Some phrases he wrote or said

«You have made us for yourself, O Lord, and our heart is restless until it rests in you.» (Confessions I, 1, 1)
«Love God and do what you will.».
«Lord, deliver me from my worst enemies: from myself.» (Condensed form of several prayers from the Confessions)
«Without you I can do nothing.». Constant theme in his late works against the Pelagians.
“Pride turned angels into demons; humility makes men into angels.” The City of God, XIV, 13
«Do not go outside yourself; return into yourself: in the interior man dwells the truth.» (De vera religione 39, 72)
«Hate the sin, love the sinner.» Condensed form of his thought (see Letter 211 and others).
“Happiness consists in rejoicing in the truth.” Work: Confessions, X, 23.
“Peace is the tranquility of order.” The City of God, XIX, 13.

To comment on or discuss this article

Click the link to access the discussions on the different networks

Categories: Home -> Philosophy

Last updated: 2025-11-19

| | | |

This site was written based on publicly available free articles from the internet.
The content of this site is available under the: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license.
You can freely copy, redistribute and modify the material, as long as the source is mentioned: liberwiki.com