GOSPLAN and the Holodomor
This article is part of the Intermediate course on Libertarianism and the Austrian School of Economics -> Marxism
Last updated: 2026-06-07
NOTE: To understand the concepts mentioned in this article it is advisable to have read the articles of Module 6: Free-Market Economics
What was Gosplan and how did it operate?
Created in 1921, Gosplan was the brain of the Soviet economy. Its mission was to abolish the anarchy of the market and replace the price system with a scientific and mathematical management of the nation's resources.
Starting in 1928, under Joseph Stalin's rule, Gosplan assumed the task of designing the celebrated Five-Year Plans (mandatory 5-year production plans). The decision-making process perfectly illustrates what Hayek called the "arrogance of reason":
The hierarchical flow (Top-Down):
- The Political Bureau (Politburo) set the general political objectives (for example: "We must triple steel production and export millions of tons of grain to finance industrial machinery").
- Gosplan translated these desires into gigantic tables of "material balances".
Micro-regulation:
- Gosplan even attempted to centrally set more than 200,000 prices and physical quotas of inputs.
- It determined how many 5-millimeter screws a plant in the Urals had to manufacture, how much fuel was to be allocated to tractors in a commune in Kazakhstan, and how many meters of fabric to assign to tailors in Kyiv.
The divorce from reality:
- Because Moscow bureaucrats lacked dispersed knowledge of time and place, local factories systematically lied in their statistical reports to artificially meet targets ("overfulfillment") and avoid being sent to the Gulag.
- If Gosplan measured the success of a nail factory by its weight, the factory produced three gigantic, useless one-ton nails; if it measured by quantity, it produced millions of tiny nails that bent on the first strike.
Forced collectivization and agricultural shock (1929-1933)
Forced Collectivization:
Gosplan determined that private agrarian property had to disappear in order to industrialize the country at forced march.
The State needed to capitalize resources. The decreed strategy was the forced collectivization of land:
- Eliminate the private property of peasants and group them into state farms (sovkhozes) and collective farms (kolkhozes).
- Efficient and independent farmers (disparagingly called kulaks) were declared enemies of the people, expropriated, deported en masse, or executed.
Setting arbitrary quotas:
- Gosplan set absurdly high grain requisition quotas based on ideological projections rather than actual harvest conditions.
- When actual production collapsed due to the destruction of private incentives and bureaucratic mismanagement, army and party detachments forcibly confiscated every last grain available in peasant households, including seeds intended for the following year's sowing, to fulfill Moscow's plan and sustain exports abroad.
Stalin reimplemented GOSPLAN fully aware that War Communism had previously generated a famine in 1921 with the very same ideas.
The Holodomor ("killing by starvation") of (1932-1933)
The knowledge clash between centralized planning and agricultural dispersed knowledge had its most tragic manifestation in Ukraine (the breadbasket of Europe), the Caucasus, and Kazakhstan:
Economically
- By suppressing property rights and the market price system, Gosplan deprived itself of the ability to evaluate real costs and needs.
- Collectivized peasants lost all biological and action-related incentives to care for the land, store seeds, or maintain livestock.
- When real production collapsed due to the intrinsic inefficiency of the system, Gosplan attributed the deficit to "bourgeois sabotage" by the kulaks.
Coercion and Centralized Blindness:
- Instead of adjusting plans to signals of scarcity (which a free market does automatically by raising prices and attracting external resources), Stalin doubled down on the interventionist wager.
- He sent the army to confiscate every last seed of consumption and reserve in Ukraine to fulfill the export quotas set in the Gosplan plan.
The Demographic and Human Result:
-
Ukraine's borders were closed to prevent the population from seeking food in other regions.
-
The result of attempting to coordinate the food supply of millions of individuals through a centralized board was paralysis and induced starvation: the Holodomor claimed the lives of between 3.5 and 5 million Ukrainians.
The General Context: The Kazakh Famine (1931-1933)
It is important to note that the Ukrainian Holodomor did not occur in isolation.
Gosplan's planning simultaneously impacted the biology of other nomadic populations.
In the Kazakh Famine (or Goloshchokin Catastrophe), forced collectivization and the attempt to settle a nomadic pastoralist people by decree destroyed their traditional ecological cycles.
Between 1.3 and 1.5 million people died, wiping out more than 30% of the ethnic Kazakh population of the era.
This article is part of the Intermediate course on Libertarianism and the Austrian School of Economics -> Marxism
| Previous topic | Next related topic | |
|---|---|---|
| <-War Communism | <---> | The Great Leap Forward-> |
Last updated: 2026-06-07
| | | |
This site was written based on publicly available free articles from the internet.
The content of this site is available under the: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license.
You can freely copy, redistribute and modify the material, as long as the source is mentioned: liberwiki.com